Dwayne McDuffie: Who Owns the Future City?

The writer and Milestone cofounder put Black inventors, teenagers and aliens into superhero comics while changing who controlled the stories themselves.

Curtis Metcalf invents the tools that make his employer rich. When he asks for a share, he discovers how little of the future he has built belongs to him. That contradiction powers Hardware, the first comic released by Milestone Media in 1993. The hero's technological brilliance is spectacular; his predicament is familiar. Dwayne McDuffie, who wrote the original series with artist Denys Cowan, made a science fiction suit of armor into a way of asking a question about labor and ownership. Who gets to profit from an inventor's mind, and who gets to decide what his invention will be used to do?

McDuffie's fiction was full of such questions. The alien Augustus Freeman, known as Icon, landed in the American South during slavery and lived into the present as a Black man. Virgil Hawkins, known as Static, was a witty teenager whose powers did not remove him from ordinary family life, friendship or prejudice. These characters inhabited Dakota, a city made for Milestone's interconnected comics. Their stories were entertaining superhero adventures, but they also tested assumptions built into the genre: whose intelligence looks heroic, whose neighborhood can sustain a myth, and whose history is allowed to travel into the future.

McDuffie helped found Milestone with Denys Cowan, Michael Davis and Derek T. Dingle. Milestone's own account describes a deal that kept the company and its creations under the founders' ownership while DC published and distributed the comics. That business structure is inseparable from the stories. Hardware criticizes an employer who appropriates a Black inventor's work. Milestone's founders sought to avoid an analogous loss of control over the worlds they invented. The fiction and its means of production were different kinds of work, but they confronted the same question of agency.

The Smithsonian's Afrofuturism reading guide places McDuffie among the comic writers central to Black speculative futures. That placement makes sense because the comics join technological imagination to histories of racial power. Yet McDuffie's achievement is not merely that Black characters appear in capes. His particular contribution lies in making their power produce social and ethical consequences that the genre had often ignored.

The inventor and the cage

Milestone published Hardware before its other launch titles. DC's collection of the first eight issues credits McDuffie as writer and Cowan among the artists, alongside the other visual contributors who made the series. The collection describes Curtis as an engineer whose high-tech armor enables him to break from Edwin Alva, the corrupt businessman who has profited from his work. The premise turns the origin story inside out. Curtis does not become a hero because a billionaire gives him equipment. He is the maker. His antagonist is the person who controls the institution in which invention becomes money.

The early issues give that conflict a pointed image. DC's account of Milestone's legacy describes a recurring metaphor of a bird escaping a cage only to strike a glass window. The apparent opening is another barrier. For Curtis, emancipation from one arrangement can lead into another limit made less visible by its transparency. A glass pane is not a chain; it can be mistaken for air. The metaphor fits the story of an inventor invited to believe that talent and hard work would grant him autonomy while his employer kept the power to define the terms.

Hardware's armor is consequently more than wish fulfillment. It is a technical answer to a social injury, built by someone whose earlier technical work had been captured. The suit makes Curtis formidable, but it does not erase the conflict that made him put it on. A superhero body can break through a wall; a corporation can own the laboratory, the patents and the public account of what happened. McDuffie's premise makes those structures part of the action. The fantasy of technological self-determination is thrilling precisely because the surrounding world has denied it.

This story was not McDuffie's alone. Cowan's visual work and the many artists, colorists and inkers credited on the original series shaped the hero's appearance and movement. Milestone grew through collective labor. McDuffie's script established a conflict and a voice; other hands made the pages that readers held. His own public comments about Static repeatedly called that character a group creation. The honesty of those credits strengthens the account of his larger achievement.

Hardware also asks what happens after a genius recognizes exploitation. Revenge is an understandable first answer, and the story gives Curtis anger enough to make it plausible. Yet a hero whose inventions have been used for somebody else's ends must decide what he will do when he can act independently. The question is not answered by the armor's engineering alone. Technology gives him options; character determines their use. That is a central tension in McDuffie's futurism.

An alien born into American history

The premise of Icon reaches further back in time. DC's character account dates Arnus's arrival on Earth to 1839. His damaged spacecraft sends him into a cotton field in the American South. A pod alters the appearance of its passenger to match the first sentient being he encounters, an enslaved woman named Miriam. She adopts him. The alien becomes Augustus Freeman, lives across generations and eventually practices law in Dakota under a name that presents him as a descendant of himself.

The science fiction mechanism is simple and devastating. The first person Arnus meets determines the form he will wear in America. That person is a woman whose freedom is denied by the society around her. The alien's ability to fly or survive extraordinary force cannot remove the historical condition into which he has arrived. His long life carries him through changes in law and custom while keeping the origin of his identity in view. He is an outsider from another planet and a Black man formed within American history; the two conditions do not cancel one another.

The hero has lived with immense power while often declining to use it openly. Raquel Ervin, a teenager who witnesses him act, presses him toward public responsibility and becomes Rocket. DC's discussion of the original series treats their disagreement as a challenge to Freeman's preference for self-reliance. He can survive by keeping his capacities quiet; she wants those capacities to matter to people beyond his household. The dynamic prevents Icon from becoming a simple Superman analogue. He is a centuries-old witness to injustice, and his young partner refuses to let witnessing substitute for action.

Raquel's presence changes the ethical scale of the story. A powerful alien can look at humanity from a long historical distance. A teenager lives with immediate material constraints: money, family, a neighborhood and the consequences of choices she must make now. DC's account notes that pregnancy becomes part of her early story. The series does not require her to stand outside ordinary life to be heroic. Her decisions about care and continuity are bound to the same city she hopes to protect. The future is made through such ordinary obligations as well as spectacular battles.

McDuffie was writing inside an established comic tradition of aliens and superpowers, yet he altered the points where that tradition touched history. The cotton field and the enslaved mother are not incidental backstory. They specify the conditions under which an extraterrestrial child becomes legible as a person in America. Raquel's challenge then turns the question from origin to action: after so much time has passed, what does this person owe to those living beside him? Icon uses an impossible lifespan to make a very earthly argument about responsibility.

A teenager who could be you

Static began with a different scale of hero. In a first-person interview, McDuffie said the Milestone founders agreed that their new universe needed a teenage protagonist. He had previously worked on an idea influenced by the younger Spider-Man, but the version Milestone published emerged from discussion among the founders. This is an important account of authorship: a writer brings an idea to a group, and the group reshapes it for a world none of them could have made alone.

Virgil Hawkins's appeal, McDuffie argued, rested in his resemblance to the audience. He loved science fiction and adventure. He became a hero because using his powers could be enjoyable and right, not because a tragedy had to confer legitimacy. That distinction sets a different emotional temperature from the familiar orphaned or vengeful superhero. Virgil has room to joke. He has room to be adolescent. His powers enlarge his life, but they do not demand that the story strip away everything else to make him worthy of them.

Milestone's Dakota is not a neutral painted backdrop. The event called the Big Bang links the emergence of many powered characters to police intervention in a gang conflict with an experimental chemical. DC's account distinguishes the public story blaming the gangs from the cause known to those who survived. In that difference between official explanation and lived knowledge, the superhero origin becomes a question of narrative power. The people most affected by the event know a story the wider city may refuse to hear.

Static's adventures can therefore move between the exhilaration of flight and the pressure of contemporary life. McDuffie said a teenager's world includes racism, school violence and homelessness, so the stories could include them without becoming lessons pasted onto an unrelated fantasy. The point is not that every issue had to cover a social topic. It is that a hero cannot be made contemporary by adding modern technology while leaving the society around him abstract. Virgil's friendships, school and neighborhood are the ordinary coordinates that make his extraordinary powers meaningful.

One story discussed by DC centers Virgil's friend Rick Stone, who comes out as gay after an attack by bigots. Virgil has to confront his own assumptions before he can offer real solidarity. The conflict is not solved by an electrical blast. The superhero action exposes an ethical limitation in the hero himself. That choice permits a popular character to be wrong, to learn and to remain part of a relationship. It gives the comic a form of growth that superpowers alone cannot supply.

From page to screen, with changes

Static Shock brought the character to television in 2000. McDuffie's interview is especially valuable because it refuses a simple story in which the comic's creator controlled every aspect of the adaptation. He said he supplied reference material and a critique of an early series bible but was not part of the show's initial development team. Later he wrote for the animated show. He credited other people with decisions that shaped its form.

One change troubled him: the animated series killed Virgil's mother, while she remained alive in the comics. McDuffie wanted a Black hero with a complete family, partly because he knew how frequently fiction used a narrower family stereotype. He also said Virgil's family experience had been intended to resemble his own. The television version found stories in its altered arrangement, but McDuffie's objection identifies something precise that the adaptation lost. A living mother was not merely a sentimental detail. She helped keep the hero's household from being organized around absence.

The animated series made other changes for the demands of a different medium and audience. McDuffie discussed Richie's development into the powered character Gear as a way of keeping the friendship active in action scenes. The transformation also answered an audience desire to see the friends fight crime together. Here technological alteration serves a relationship. Gear's powers matter because they change how two boys can share a story, not only because they add another device to a battle.

McDuffie observed that the show's world could connect more readily to DC's established animated heroes than the original comics had connected to DC continuity. The comic's separation was bound to ownership and editorial control. Television found different ways to stage crossovers. The contrast shows how a fictional universe depends on contracts, studios and formats as much as on plot. Static could inhabit one continuity on the page and another on screen, while the underlying character remained recognizable.

He also described the difficulty of sustaining a successful animated show without merchandise and licensing income. That material fact belongs near the work, because it reveals the economic pressure on a Black superhero's visibility. An audience can love a character, a series can reach viewers, and still the industry can decide that its financial structure does not support more episodes. McDuffie's account does not diminish the show's achievement. It clarifies the conditions under which popular futures are allowed to continue.

A universe and its makers

McDuffie died in 2011. Milestone's characters continued in print and animation, sometimes changing hands and contexts. The company's history credits its founders' insistence on ownership as a foundation for that survival. It was a collective decision made before the first issue appeared. Without it, the stories of Curtis, Virgil, Augustus and Raquel would have had a different relationship to the people who created them.

Cowan drew and cofounded; Davis and Dingle helped build the company; collaborators developed individual titles; animators and actors transformed stories for television. McDuffie wrote vital parts of the universe and helped make the structure that held it. His distinct achievement lies partly in knowing that a future large enough for many kinds of Black heroes also required many kinds of makers.

Krull's conversation with Kya Kyani follows a Black queer musician making work on her own terms while navigating an industry that tries to narrow her identity. McDuffie's medium and career were different, but Milestone was also built around Black creators' authority over their images and stories. Dakota's armored inventor, alien lawyer and electrified teenager belong to a comic world shaped by that insistence on agency.

The best image of McDuffie's project may still be the bird at the window in Hardware. A hero sees an opening and strikes an invisible barrier. The response is neither to deny the barrier nor to abandon the idea of flight. It is to learn who put the glass there, who claims the space beyond it and how one might make a different route. Milestone's comics made that question exciting for readers while its founders pursued an answer in their own publishing deal. Their future city was fictional. Their claim to make and own it was real.

This might interest you as well